What Attorney Client Privilege Actually Protects?

Attorney client privilege keeps your private conversations with your lawyer out of court. In Pennsylvania the protection is written into law at 42 Pa.C.S. Section 5928 for civil matters and Section 5916 for criminal matters. Your lawyer cannot be forced to testify about what you told them in confidence, and you cannot be compelled to reveal it either. The protection covers communication made in private for the purpose of getting legal advice. It survives after your case ends. A few things can break it, including talking in front of other people and seeking help to commit a future crime. This article explains what is covered, what is not, and how to avoid losing the protection by accident.

What the Privilege Covers in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania courts apply four requirements. All four must be met for the privilege to attach.

Requirement

What It Means
A communication

Something said or written, not a physical object

Between a client and an attorney

The relationship must exist or be forming
Made in confidence

Private, without outsiders listening in

For legal advice

The purpose is obtaining or giving legal help

Miss one of these and the protection may not apply. A conversation held in a crowded room fails the confidence test. A chat with your lawyer about weekend plans fails the legal advice test.

The Protection Runs Both Ways

For many years, Pennsylvania’s statute appeared to protect only what the client said to the lawyer. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court settled the question in Gillard v. AIG Insurance Company, decided in 2011.

In Gillard, the Court held that the privilege works in a two way fashion. It protects confidential communications from client to attorney and from attorney to client, when made for the purpose of obtaining or providing legal advice. That means your lawyer’s written advice back to you is protected too, alongside your own words.

This matters in practice. Emails, letters, and memos from your attorney about your case carry the same protection as what you told them.

Privilege and Confidentiality Are Two Different Things

People use these terms as if they mean the same thing. They do not, and the difference works in your favor.

Privilege is an evidence rule. It stops your communications from being used as testimony or evidence in a legal proceeding.

Confidentiality is an ethics duty, and it is broader. Rule 1.6 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct sets this duty. A lawyer must not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client consents or an exception applies. This covers information from any source, not just what you said directly.

Protection

What It Is How Broad
Attorney client privilege A rule of evidence in court

Confidential communications for legal advice

Duty of confidentiality

An ethics rule binding the lawyer

All information relating to the representation

Does It Apply Before You Hire the Lawyer?

Yes. This is the question people worry about most, and the answer is reassuring.

Under Rule 1.18 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct, a lawyer who discusses a possible case with you owes duties to you as a prospective client. What you share in that consultation is protected even if you never hire that lawyer and never pay a fee.

That is why being open at a first meeting is the right move. Whether you are discussing a criminal charge or a business dispute, holding back a difficult fact only limits the advice you get.

What the Privilege Does Not Cover

The protection has real limits. Knowing them prevents costly mistakes.

  • Facts themselves. You cannot hide a fact by telling your lawyer about it. If you ran a red light, the privilege protects your conversation, not the event.
  • Physical evidence. Handing something to your lawyer does not shield the object.
  • Business or personal advice. If the talk is not about legal advice, it may fall outside the privilege.
  • Conversations with others. Talking to a friend about your case is not protected, and that friend can be called to testify.
  • Future crimes. Advice sought to commit or hide a crime or fraud is not protected.

How People Lose the Protection by Accident

Waiver is the most common way privilege disappears, and it usually happens without anyone meaning to.

Talking in Front of Other People

Privilege requires privacy. Pennsylvania courts have long held that the presence of a third party during an attorney client conversation can waive the protection. A spouse, a parent, or a friend sitting in for support may be enough to break it.

There is an exception. If the third party is necessary or useful to the lawyer giving advice, the protection can survive. An interpreter or an accountant brought in to explain figures may qualify. A friend along for comfort usually does not.

Sharing the Information Later

Repeating privileged advice to someone outside the relationship can waive it. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed this in BouSamra v. Excela Health, decided in 2019, where legal advice was forwarded to an outside public relations firm. Sharing it that way waived the privilege.

The lesson is simple. Do not forward your lawyer’s advice to people who are not part of the case.

Posting About Your Case

Social media creates the same problem in a faster way. Posting details of your case, or discussing it in a group chat, puts that information outside the protected relationship. This comes up often in injury claims, where insurers review public posts.

The Crime Fraud Exception

This is the most significant exception, and it is narrow but firm.

Pennsylvania recognizes a crime fraud exception, set out by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in In re Investigating Grand Jury of Philadelphia County in 1991. Communications made for the purpose of committing a crime or fraud fall outside the privilege.

The distinction matters. Telling your lawyer about something you already did is generally protected. Asking your lawyer for help carrying out a future crime is not. The exception looks forward, not backward.

How Long Does the Privilege Last?

The protection does not expire when your case closes. It continues after the representation ends.

It also generally survives the client’s death, which is why estate matters can involve privilege questions years later. This comes up in estate and probate work when family members dispute what a parent intended.

How to Protect the Privilege in Practice

A few habits keep the protection intact.

  1. Meet your lawyer in private, without friends or family in the room.
  2. Use your own phone and email, not a work account your employer can access.
  3. Do not forward your attorney’s emails to anyone else.
  4. Do not discuss your case on social media or in group chats.
  5. Tell your lawyer the hard facts first, since they are protected.
  6. Ask your lawyer before bringing anyone to a meeting.

That second point surprises people. Email sent through an employer’s system may be accessible to the employer, which can undercut the claim that the communication was confidential.

Final Thoughts

Attorney client privilege protects confidential communications made to get legal advice, and Pennsylvania writes that protection into its statutes. It runs both ways, it applies before you formally hire anyone, and it lasts after your case ends. It can be lost by talking in front of others, sharing the advice later, or seeking help with a future crime.

The practical takeaway is to speak freely with your lawyer and carefully with everyone else. Jameson Stone Law offers a free consultation at its Camp Hill office on East Trindle Road, and that conversation is protected from the start. Call the firm today to talk through your situation in private.

Related Posts